I remember sitting in my ninth grade English class, collectively pouring over To Kill A Mockingbird with 20 of my classmates. Atticus Finch, the closest thing even fiction had to perfection, captivated us with his brilliance and ahead-of-the-times thinking, and Boo Radley’s redemption as a character became a literary technique we could all learn from.
Years later, as I was introduced to the literary excellence of Truman Capote and learned of his childhood friendship with Harper Lee (To Kill A Mockingbird’s Dill is based on a childhood Capote) my father and I debated, over several dinners and family functions, how much of the novel’s success can actually be attributed to Lee. “It has the classic Capote arc, and ends in the same way much of Capote’s work does— with redemption of a sympathetic character,” he argues. As a student of Capote’s genius, I vehemently deny his claims. Though she may have been inspired by his words and his writing style, that is a far cry from ripping of his ideas or, as some have suggested, having Capote ghost write the novel and taking the credit. I am also inspired by Capote’s writing — though one can hardly give him credit for my words. Even, in a hypothetical world, if she asked him for advice, or a quick read-over (again, who wouldn’t? You have a successful writer at your disposal), I hesitate to throw faith in any Capote influence in the novel.
The time has come again to reopen the debate, as Harper Lee has announced that, more than 50 years after the release of her famous novel, a sequel is in the works. Lee, who is now 88, will release Go Set a Watchman on July 14. The sequel will centre around Scout Finch as an adult. Capote died in 1984, and Harper Lee has been notoriously private from the public image, despite her massive success. Though reports have surfaced saying that Lee forgot this manuscript entirely (she is reportedly ill) and was delighted at the discovery, I will venture, here, to say that I strongly doubt that she has been sitting on this sequel since before 1984, since an age when an already troubled Capote could’ve helped her again.
The literary world (which even consists of celebrities who seem to be well-read) has had an overwhelmingly positive reaction to the news of a To Kill a Mockingbird sequel. The book has nestled among the iconic American novels for half a century, and the characters remain beloved by the American populace. Though I, too, am excited to read a follow-up novel to a tale I really enjoyed - I am curious to see how much of Capote’s influence will be present in this novel. I feel that Go Set a Watchman could be the one that finally settles the debate in Capote’s involvement in the novel — a controversy that has always been an undertone in the book’s success. Lee, though, will no longer be known as the woman who only wrote one successful novel. And I, for one, will be sure to pick up a copy.
Years later, as I was introduced to the literary excellence of Truman Capote and learned of his childhood friendship with Harper Lee (To Kill A Mockingbird’s Dill is based on a childhood Capote) my father and I debated, over several dinners and family functions, how much of the novel’s success can actually be attributed to Lee. “It has the classic Capote arc, and ends in the same way much of Capote’s work does— with redemption of a sympathetic character,” he argues. As a student of Capote’s genius, I vehemently deny his claims. Though she may have been inspired by his words and his writing style, that is a far cry from ripping of his ideas or, as some have suggested, having Capote ghost write the novel and taking the credit. I am also inspired by Capote’s writing — though one can hardly give him credit for my words. Even, in a hypothetical world, if she asked him for advice, or a quick read-over (again, who wouldn’t? You have a successful writer at your disposal), I hesitate to throw faith in any Capote influence in the novel.
The time has come again to reopen the debate, as Harper Lee has announced that, more than 50 years after the release of her famous novel, a sequel is in the works. Lee, who is now 88, will release Go Set a Watchman on July 14. The sequel will centre around Scout Finch as an adult. Capote died in 1984, and Harper Lee has been notoriously private from the public image, despite her massive success. Though reports have surfaced saying that Lee forgot this manuscript entirely (she is reportedly ill) and was delighted at the discovery, I will venture, here, to say that I strongly doubt that she has been sitting on this sequel since before 1984, since an age when an already troubled Capote could’ve helped her again.
The literary world (which even consists of celebrities who seem to be well-read) has had an overwhelmingly positive reaction to the news of a To Kill a Mockingbird sequel. The book has nestled among the iconic American novels for half a century, and the characters remain beloved by the American populace. Though I, too, am excited to read a follow-up novel to a tale I really enjoyed - I am curious to see how much of Capote’s influence will be present in this novel. I feel that Go Set a Watchman could be the one that finally settles the debate in Capote’s involvement in the novel — a controversy that has always been an undertone in the book’s success. Lee, though, will no longer be known as the woman who only wrote one successful novel. And I, for one, will be sure to pick up a copy.